On Wednesday, Arizona's Independent Redistricting Commission (two Democrats, two Republicans and a tie-breaking independent) unanimously approved a new congressional map featuring four GOP seats, three Democratic seats and two highly competitive seats. In the short term, it could flip the delegation from 5D-4R to as wide as 6R-3D in 2022. But, Democrats have longer-term upside in Phoenix and Tucson seats trending their way.

The commission's uneasy consensus is a remarkable achievement in itself, considering last decade's process descended into a debacle after the independent chair sided 3-2 with Democrats and GOP legislators impeached her. This time, neither side got everything it wanted, though Democrats are still a bit irked at chair Erika Neuberg and Republicans see the final product as unraveling the current plan they view as a Democratic gerrymander.

Like the old map, the new map would have split 5-4 for Joe Biden in 2020. But two of those Biden seats were near-ties: the new Scottsdale/North Phoenix 1st CD went for Biden by a point, and the new suburban Tucson 6th CD voted for him by just a tenth

More from the Cook Political Report

Where History Rhymed and Where It Didn’t
National Politics
AW
GOP won the votes, but not the seats
National Politics
Photo of Charlie Cook